Hey guys so I want to upgrade my wheels soon and am looking to get my wheels super flush with the fenders or slightly out by roughly 5mm or less. I’m looking into either 19x9.5 front and rear or staggered with 19x8.5 front and 19x9.5 rear. The non staggered setup has +20mm or +40mm options and the staggered i’ve found +20mm all around or +15 front +20 rear. Which options would achieve my desired look? Let me know how your guy’s cars look.

 

19x9.5 +20 running 245/40s will get you there, are you going to be lowered? Also if you have an S model be sure to confirm brake clearance.
Here's Rynes setup, he's running 9+20 in front on 255s, if you run 245s on the 9.5+20 the fit at the fender will be the same but the actual wheel edge will be 6mm further out, so if that's too much poke you'd have to go w/ a more positive offset.
https://www.myg37.com/forums/brakes-...ml#post3917336

 

 

They will tuck, but at stock height they will be poking a fair amount. Something in a +30 would be easier to run stock and you could run a bit more tire. What wheel brand/model are you considering?

 

 

Here's another example running 10.5 +25 on 255s
https://www.myg37.com/forums/brakes-...ml#post3877365
This setup will be 7mm out from the Rohanna 9.5"+20s and if you run a 245 this will give you an additional 5mm to the fender, so a net 11mm inside that setup.