When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
^^Recall, it was a broken kia (optima sx 2011 that wouldn't drive straight) that got me into the G in the first place. Will they be having engine recalls with this one too.... Or have they learned their lesson.
Although I went to KIA a few months ago to check out their Stinger, yesterday I saw my first Stinger GT in a parking lot, in yellow, and took another moment to walk around. Damn fine looking car. Just the right proportions. Love that hatch design.
I like the idea of the stinger but I cant deal with its looks in any colour but black...too much fake venty goodness going on.
^^Recall, it was a broken kia (optima sx 2011 that wouldn't drive straight) that got me into the G in the first place. Will they be having engine recalls with this one too.... Or have they learned their lesson.
my fingers are crossed that the stinger/G70 are a signal from Kia and Hyundai that they are investing quality going forward as they try to establish more premium brand offerings
I'll admit there are times I'd like to have a station wagon... If I had to take the neighbors' kids to school or shop for the wife, get some lawn supplies at the Home Depot... maybe. :-) But, not when I'm driving Big Sur. There, I'd rather drive what the author calls unimaginative, boring three-box designs. :-) A nice four door sedan like a G37, Q50 or even a four door Maserati. My humble opinion, of course.
Wouldn't driving dynamics be the same or better (weight distribution) in a wagon/hatch than a sedan?
Originally Posted by 4DRZ
I agree. Sedans are much easier to make with good styling compared to an suv or a hatch or wagon. When was the last time you saw an suv or wagon and said, "Wow that looks awesome! I NEED one of those!!"
Sorry, but that styling does nothing for me. I really don't like the wagon look and the wheels and fender vent look like they came off of the Kia Stinger.
But I do like the look of this Jaguar XE SV Project 8. Much more aggressive.
I will say for me the XE checks all the aesthetic boxes. Drove one 6 months ago. Only issue for me was it needed better brakes I think. Seats were also a little less bolstered.
I will say for me the XE checks all the aesthetic boxes. Drove one 6 months ago. Only issue for me was it needed better brakes I think. Seats were also a little less bolstered.
I haven't driven one, but I did visit my local Jag dealership to check it out. My take-away: this car looks so-o-o much better on-line than it actually does in person. When you sit in the XE, and walk around the car with your own eyes, it's just not that impressive.
I left Jag thinking that I already own the better car.
You flip around a lot, the other week you were comparing the interior of the G to a Sentra
In comparison to the F-Type... yeah, that's true.
I was expecting a Sedan-like interpretation of the F-Type in the XE, and was hugely disappointed. The XE is just a bread & butter sedan, whereas the F-Type is special.
You could also argue, how can I be impressed with the Stinger, but unimpressed with the XE? That's because the Stinger is punching up with something new and unique, whereas the XE is punching down with a basic design.
Last edited by Rochester; Jun 15, 2018 at 12:28 PM.