nGc 5AT owners..any regrets?
Thread Starter
Registered Member
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 140
Likes: 0
From: Northern VA
nGc 5AT owners..any regrets?
Just wondering for those of you in the club who have the 5AT, do you ever regret not getting the 6MT?
When I purchased the car about 5 months ago, I was just too excited I didnt care that I was getting an auto. I have never driven a manual before (unfortunately
) and there was no way I was considering learning on a brand new 35K dollar sports car. Lately I've been wondering if I acted to quickly in purchasing the 5AT. I could have learned on some beater car and then picked up a 6MT. During the week I dont mind the 5AT, but on the weekends I sometimes second guess myself and wonder how much more fun I would have with a 6MT. MM mode is pretty cool, but I know it's not the same without a clutch.
I also hate it when people ask "auto or stick" and I say auto. And they always say "oh..why?"
OH well, I still love my car and I am not going to trade it in for a less just to get a 6MT like others have done. I'll just wait for the next G35 to come out then probably get the 6MT then.
When I purchased the car about 5 months ago, I was just too excited I didnt care that I was getting an auto. I have never driven a manual before (unfortunately
) and there was no way I was considering learning on a brand new 35K dollar sports car. Lately I've been wondering if I acted to quickly in purchasing the 5AT. I could have learned on some beater car and then picked up a 6MT. During the week I dont mind the 5AT, but on the weekends I sometimes second guess myself and wonder how much more fun I would have with a 6MT. MM mode is pretty cool, but I know it's not the same without a clutch. I also hate it when people ask "auto or stick" and I say auto. And they always say "oh..why?"
OH well, I still love my car and I am not going to trade it in for a less just to get a 6MT like others have done. I'll just wait for the next G35 to come out then probably get the 6MT then.
I've said it many times about this subject. Grass is usually greener on the other side. Its easy for manual owners to say you should get a manual, its the only way to drive the car. Everyone's situation is different.
This is my first AUTO car. I just can't handle the amount of traffic I sit in to get a manual car right now. I have no regrets. Sure there are days when we are on spirited drives that I wish I had a manual and then there are the rush hour bumper to bumper traffic jams too where Im happy.
If I didnt get my job that I'm at, I'd still have my old BMW and no G for me. I loved that car but unfortunately it being 5 speed, I just had no choice.
This is my first AUTO car. I just can't handle the amount of traffic I sit in to get a manual car right now. I have no regrets. Sure there are days when we are on spirited drives that I wish I had a manual and then there are the rush hour bumper to bumper traffic jams too where Im happy.
If I didnt get my job that I'm at, I'd still have my old BMW and no G for me. I loved that car but unfortunately it being 5 speed, I just had no choice.
I have two MT's and my gf just got an AT. MT takes it hands down in anything but bumper to bumper... in heavy traffic, it is nice to be in the AT and not feel like you're killing your clutch by constantly shifting N-1-2-N, but as soon as traffic eases, my left foot gets restless and I often find it subconsciously stomping on the foot rest to the beat of the music... AT is also nice in that it permits talking on the phone much more easily, as I don't always have bluetooth activated in the car...
I love my AT .. and its faster anyways 
... i really wanted a 6MT .... but my dad insisted that i got an AT ...since it was a present from my parents ... and I couldn't get over the fact that i was getting a G35.... i really cared less at that point.... however with that being said .. i still have no regrets ... and i love my car .... i'm finally gonna get to drive her today 
can't waitt...
... i really wanted a 6MT .... but my dad insisted that i got an AT ...since it was a present from my parents ... and I couldn't get over the fact that i was getting a G35.... i really cared less at that point.... however with that being said .. i still have no regrets ... and i love my car .... i'm finally gonna get to drive her today can't waitt...
This is my first manaul car and up until the time I purchased it, I've never driven one for more than 5 minutes. At first it sucks in traffic but after 5 months, I'm use to it. From what I've heard, the '05 lighter clutch might make a huge difference if you're commute includes traffic. Besides, it gives me something to do in boring *** traffic.
Trending Topics
Thread Starter
Registered Member
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 140
Likes: 0
From: Northern VA
Originally Posted by arjunz
I love my AT .. and its faster anyways ... i really wanted a 6MT .... but my dad insisted that i got an AT ...since it was a present from my parents ... and I couldn't get over the fact that i was getting a G35.... i really cared less at that point.... however with that being said .. i still have no regrets ... and i love my car .... i'm finally gonna get to drive her today can't waitt...
... i really wanted a 6MT .... but my dad insisted that i got an AT ...since it was a present from my parents ... and I couldn't get over the fact that i was getting a G35.... i really cared less at that point.... however with that being said .. i still have no regrets ... and i love my car .... i'm finally gonna get to drive her today can't waitt...
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
From: Fairfax, VA
Originally Posted by Espresso
This is my first manaul car and up until the time I purchased it, I've never driven one for more than 5 minutes. At first it sucks in traffic but after 5 months, I'm use to it. From what I've heard, the '05 lighter clutch might make a huge difference if you're commute includes traffic. Besides, it gives me something to do in boring *** traffic.
Yeah I've driven the 05 clutch and it feels like feather compared to the 04 clutch which is like a spring action.
Registered User
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,365
Likes: 0
From: Vienna (DC Area)
Originally Posted by stylez09
Just wondering for those of you in the club who have the 5AT, do you ever regret not getting the 6MT?
When I purchased the car about 5 months ago, I was just too excited I didnt care that I was getting an auto. I have never driven a manual before (unfortunately ) and there was no way I was considering learning on a brand new 35K dollar sports car. Lately I've been wondering if I acted to quickly in purchasing the 5AT. I could have learned on some beater car and then picked up a 6MT. During the week I dont mind the 5AT, but on the weekends I sometimes second guess myself and wonder how much more fun I would have with a 6MT. MM mode is pretty cool, but I know it's not the same without a clutch.
I also hate it when people ask "auto or stick" and I say auto. And they always say "oh..why?"
OH well, I still love my car and I am not going to trade it in for a less just to get a 6MT like others have done. I'll just wait for the next G35 to come out then probably get the 6MT then.
When I purchased the car about 5 months ago, I was just too excited I didnt care that I was getting an auto. I have never driven a manual before (unfortunately
) and there was no way I was considering learning on a brand new 35K dollar sports car. Lately I've been wondering if I acted to quickly in purchasing the 5AT. I could have learned on some beater car and then picked up a 6MT. During the week I dont mind the 5AT, but on the weekends I sometimes second guess myself and wonder how much more fun I would have with a 6MT. MM mode is pretty cool, but I know it's not the same without a clutch. I also hate it when people ask "auto or stick" and I say auto. And they always say "oh..why?"
OH well, I still love my car and I am not going to trade it in for a less just to get a 6MT like others have done. I'll just wait for the next G35 to come out then probably get the 6MT then.
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
From: Fairfax, VA
Originally Posted by Byrnie
I was in the same exact situation as you stylez. If and when I get a second car and it's a sports coupe/car I will definitely get it in manual and use it for weekends and fridays. All in all I love having the automatic because it still is quick but if I had to do it all over again I'd do the same thing. I can shift if I want or cruise and I love that feature. I'm waiting for infiniti to come out with their version of Audi's DSG and BMW's SMG with no bugs in it.
byrnie...you shouldn't be driving.... you should have a driver.
Registered User
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,365
Likes: 0
From: Vienna (DC Area)
Originally Posted by mbq62
byrnie...you shouldn't be driving.... you should have a driver.
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 931
Likes: 0
From: Centreville, VA
I do regret. A lot.
it's been 5 months and i only have 2500 miles on my car.
2~3 cars waiting outside...meaning i don't drive much w/ my G
whenever i think i am going to get in a traffic, i take either of my 2 other AT cars (or you can say 3...anyways)
i made a mistake
if you have a winter car/daily, go w/ manual
it's been 5 months and i only have 2500 miles on my car.
2~3 cars waiting outside...meaning i don't drive much w/ my G
whenever i think i am going to get in a traffic, i take either of my 2 other AT cars (or you can say 3...anyways)
i made a mistake
if you have a winter car/daily, go w/ manual
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
