I know there are full dash wrap kits, but I only need one piece. Anybody know of a good way to cover/wrap this plastic console piece with the cutouts for Snow and seat heater dials? Those stains will not go away

 

If you can separate the matte plastic piece from the console, I'd try painting with spray vinyl dye (not spray *paint*). You can get it at Autozone etc.

Being that the surface there is textured, you'd have a heck of a time getting thin vinyl to stick, and anything thick (like a real CF overlay) will look off if nothing else is replaced.

 

I ended up masking, prepping, and rattle-canned it with appliance paint. Turned out great IMO, lets see how it holds up in a year.

 

That looks great, better than a wrap

 

If you spray it, HIGHLY encourage using VHT vinyl dye rather than generic rattle-can. It bonds with the plastic better.

https://www.vhtpaint.com/specialty/vht-vinyl-dye Still a spray, relatively cheap, super easy to use, and available all over the place.