S vs. non S?
Z Meets Wall: We Investigate Why the NISMO Z's Brakes Failed at Lightning Lap - Feature - Car and Driver
I'm pretty sure he is talking about the Nismo 370Z's run at Virginia Motor Speedway. Went into the wall on Turn One (after a few laps) because the pads disintegrated. As a result, Nissan started offering a $500+ performance brake pad option for the Sport brakes.
However, Beer, I believe it was mentioned (perhaps by Mike) that the calipers are fine, but the pads would need to be replaced, which is what C&D said after the accident.
Edit
C&D also recommends you upgrade the brake fluid and install brake-cooling ducts, as there isn't quite enough airflow to the brakes to cool them off (on the 370, not 100% sure on the g37).
I'm pretty sure he is talking about the Nismo 370Z's run at Virginia Motor Speedway. Went into the wall on Turn One (after a few laps) because the pads disintegrated. As a result, Nissan started offering a $500+ performance brake pad option for the Sport brakes.
However, Beer, I believe it was mentioned (perhaps by Mike) that the calipers are fine, but the pads would need to be replaced, which is what C&D said after the accident.
Edit
C&D also recommends you upgrade the brake fluid and install brake-cooling ducts, as there isn't quite enough airflow to the brakes to cool them off (on the 370, not 100% sure on the g37).As far as tires I'd never say buy cheap light tires. Real 1-piece forged tires are super expensive. We tend to think our crappy wheels we buy are actually race tested..they are not. And considering most will tell you if you race with 20" tires anyway you're not really a racer.
As I said, when I had a Twin Turbo 350Z i had the stock wheels and when I went to 20s it was a huge difference in the feel of acceleration. Does that equate anything to cornering? No, of course not, but wheels are the heaviest and farthest from the engine and therefore require the most torque to rotate. So they will make the biggest noticeable difference in performance out there.
If you get a 6MT (which I recommend anyway) you don't have the option.....and you can sell those parts anyway and make money toward different stuff.
Exactly, They did a follow up and changed everything but the calipers and still had the failure..with the optional R pads. They are the same brakes as the 370 so they should have the same issues. There are few brakes on cars that really can take track use...racing is hard on all equipment. Race brakes won't work well on the street because they work at a higher temp and therefore increase normal stopping distances.
As far as tires I'd never say buy cheap light tires. Real 1-piece forged tires are super expensive. We tend to think our crappy wheels we buy are actually race tested..they are not. And considering most will tell you if you race with 20" tires anyway you're not really a racer.
As I said, when I had a Twin Turbo 350Z i had the stock wheels and when I went to 20s it was a huge difference in the feel of acceleration. Does that equate anything to cornering? No, of course not, but wheels are the heaviest and farthest from the engine and therefore require the most torque to rotate. So they will make the biggest noticeable difference in performance out there.
If you get a 6MT (which I recommend anyway) you don't have the option.....and you can sell those parts anyway and make money toward different stuff.
As far as tires I'd never say buy cheap light tires. Real 1-piece forged tires are super expensive. We tend to think our crappy wheels we buy are actually race tested..they are not. And considering most will tell you if you race with 20" tires anyway you're not really a racer.
As I said, when I had a Twin Turbo 350Z i had the stock wheels and when I went to 20s it was a huge difference in the feel of acceleration. Does that equate anything to cornering? No, of course not, but wheels are the heaviest and farthest from the engine and therefore require the most torque to rotate. So they will make the biggest noticeable difference in performance out there.
If you get a 6MT (which I recommend anyway) you don't have the option.....and you can sell those parts anyway and make money toward different stuff.
Race brakes not working well on the street? I've daily driven with race pads on for years. The only tradeoff is cost and noise. A cold race pad will not have the mu of a hot race pad its in optimal temperature range, but it will still have more bite than a street pad. For example, a street pad may have a mu of 0.35 across it's temperature range of 0-600F A race pad may have a mu of 0.45 from 0-300F, 0.55 from 300-600F, and 0.60 from 600-900F, and 0.65 from 900-2000F, and then go back down from there. Note that AT ALL TIMES, the race pad has more mu. Here's a quick reference for you. andrew-racing.com/file/630-Hawk+compound+comparison+chart.pdf
What do you consider a "race tested" rim? RPF1s are one of the best choices you can make for wheels. They're light, and they're cheap, and are TUV, JWL, and VIA. They're not forged. Do you understand the difference between weight, strength, and rigidity? Street driving is far harder on a rim than driving on a track. There are no potholes on track, and hitting a curb is still hitting a curb.
Wheels being furthest from the engine? Heaviest and requiring the most torque to rotate? I think you forgot the chassis itself. I'm sorry your car didn't make enough torque for you to do a wheelie, but the chassis itself is also rotating. You just didn't have enough grip and/or torque to actually get a noticeable rotation. You'd have a lower ET at the drag strip by getting better drag tires than with lighter rims. Easily.
Stop regurgitating information you read on the internet, and provide either real results or personal experience. The point of this post is, the OP is trying to determine what is more cost effective, and you're just telling him to buy stuff he doesn't need.
[quote=Beer Magazine;3361815]. And considering most will tell you if you race with 20" tires anyway you're not really a racer. /quote]
This so hard haha.
That brake issue is a little outside my scope. The speeds that Z were going were far and above what I expect from from my races, at least without altering the entire setup of my car prior which is something I reserve for our teams actual RACE cars rather than I track weekend car which is what this is.
There won't be any roll cage, Racing slicks, toe hooks, kill-switches or anything like that. I'm basically tuning up a dealership vehicle, taking it to the track and running for time to get nods and murmers of approval from buys in sunglasses leaning on the hoods of camaros and corvettes.
If that doesn't put it in perspective consider this...I'll probably be drinking beer out of a cooler in between laps...
I'm sorry I didn't clear this up for you guys, Sometime sI like to listen to ou guys remonstrate on racing theory so I forget what I asked in the first place
This so hard haha.
That brake issue is a little outside my scope. The speeds that Z were going were far and above what I expect from from my races, at least without altering the entire setup of my car prior which is something I reserve for our teams actual RACE cars rather than I track weekend car which is what this is.
There won't be any roll cage, Racing slicks, toe hooks, kill-switches or anything like that. I'm basically tuning up a dealership vehicle, taking it to the track and running for time to get nods and murmers of approval from buys in sunglasses leaning on the hoods of camaros and corvettes.
If that doesn't put it in perspective consider this...I'll probably be drinking beer out of a cooler in between laps...
I'm sorry I didn't clear this up for you guys, Sometime sI like to listen to ou guys remonstrate on racing theory so I forget what I asked in the first place
I'm sorry, but you just lost all credibility here. Time to separate some fact from fiction.
Race brakes not working well on the street? I've daily driven with race pads on for years. The only tradeoff is cost and noise. A cold race pad will not have the mu of a hot race pad its in optimal temperature range, but it will still have more bite than a street pad. For example, a street pad may have a mu of 0.35 across it's temperature range of 0-600F A race pad may have a mu of 0.45 from 0-300F, 0.55 from 300-600F, and 0.60 from 600-900F, and 0.65 from 900-2000F, and then go back down from there. Note that AT ALL TIMES, the race pad has more mu. Here's a quick reference for you. andrew-racing.com/file/630-Hawk+compound+comparison+chart.pdf
What do you consider a "race tested" rim? RPF1s are one of the best choices you can make for wheels. They're light, and they're cheap, and are TUV, JWL, and VIA. They're not forged. Do you understand the difference between weight, strength, and rigidity? Street driving is far harder on a rim than driving on a track. There are no potholes on track, and hitting a curb is still hitting a curb.
Wheels being furthest from the engine? Heaviest and requiring the most torque to rotate? I think you forgot the chassis itself. I'm sorry your car didn't make enough torque for you to do a wheelie, but the chassis itself is also rotating. You just didn't have enough grip and/or torque to actually get a noticeable rotation. You'd have a lower ET at the drag strip by getting better drag tires than with lighter rims. Easily.
Stop regurgitating information you read on the internet, and provide either real results or personal experience. The point of this post is, the OP is trying to determine what is more cost effective, and you're just telling him to buy stuff he doesn't need.
Race brakes not working well on the street? I've daily driven with race pads on for years. The only tradeoff is cost and noise. A cold race pad will not have the mu of a hot race pad its in optimal temperature range, but it will still have more bite than a street pad. For example, a street pad may have a mu of 0.35 across it's temperature range of 0-600F A race pad may have a mu of 0.45 from 0-300F, 0.55 from 300-600F, and 0.60 from 600-900F, and 0.65 from 900-2000F, and then go back down from there. Note that AT ALL TIMES, the race pad has more mu. Here's a quick reference for you. andrew-racing.com/file/630-Hawk+compound+comparison+chart.pdf
What do you consider a "race tested" rim? RPF1s are one of the best choices you can make for wheels. They're light, and they're cheap, and are TUV, JWL, and VIA. They're not forged. Do you understand the difference between weight, strength, and rigidity? Street driving is far harder on a rim than driving on a track. There are no potholes on track, and hitting a curb is still hitting a curb.
Wheels being furthest from the engine? Heaviest and requiring the most torque to rotate? I think you forgot the chassis itself. I'm sorry your car didn't make enough torque for you to do a wheelie, but the chassis itself is also rotating. You just didn't have enough grip and/or torque to actually get a noticeable rotation. You'd have a lower ET at the drag strip by getting better drag tires than with lighter rims. Easily.
Stop regurgitating information you read on the internet, and provide either real results or personal experience. The point of this post is, the OP is trying to determine what is more cost effective, and you're just telling him to buy stuff he doesn't need.
Come on. I can do simply physics experiments for you if you want to get childish.
I'm not debating grip like you are. I'm talking about rotating mass which takes 4x the energy to move than non-rotational weight. Weight reduction anywhere is better than heavy. It's far cheaper to reduce rotating mass of wheels than it is to acid dip a chassis.
So if you want to swing your internet ***** around go ahead. I'll just laugh with you. If you feel the stock parts are good because you wear out brakes...I can't help you.
I'll explain pads to you. Race pads are meant to work at higher temps and constant use. Street brakes work better at lower temps and will stop better because they are made to "panic" stop shorter (and for those cool online stats you like to think I'm looking up). So unless you are really heating up your brakes on the street, race pads aren't ideal..but I guess maybe you live your life 1 street light at at time?
Last edited by G37Sam; Feb 14, 2012 at 01:31 PM. Reason: Calm down
[quote=kingdavid;3361864]
The article shows the weakness of the brakes. While you may not try to stop from 130-30, repeated 95-30 will produce lots of wear.
And I'll bring the beer for that race day!
. And considering most will tell you if you race with 20" tires anyway you're not really a racer. /quote]
This so hard haha.
That brake issue is a little outside my scope. The speeds that Z were going were far and above what I expect from from my races, at least without altering the entire setup of my car prior which is something I reserve for our teams actual RACE cars rather than I track weekend car which is what this is.
There won't be any roll cage, Racing slicks, toe hooks, kill-switches or anything like that. I'm basically tuning up a dealership vehicle, taking it to the track and running for time to get nods and murmers of approval from buys in sunglasses leaning on the hoods of camaros and corvettes.
If that doesn't put it in perspective consider this...I'll probably be drinking beer out of a cooler in between laps...
I'm sorry I didn't clear this up for you guys, Sometime sI like to listen to ou guys remonstrate on racing theory so I forget what I asked in the first place
This so hard haha.
That brake issue is a little outside my scope. The speeds that Z were going were far and above what I expect from from my races, at least without altering the entire setup of my car prior which is something I reserve for our teams actual RACE cars rather than I track weekend car which is what this is.
There won't be any roll cage, Racing slicks, toe hooks, kill-switches or anything like that. I'm basically tuning up a dealership vehicle, taking it to the track and running for time to get nods and murmers of approval from buys in sunglasses leaning on the hoods of camaros and corvettes.
If that doesn't put it in perspective consider this...I'll probably be drinking beer out of a cooler in between laps...
I'm sorry I didn't clear this up for you guys, Sometime sI like to listen to ou guys remonstrate on racing theory so I forget what I asked in the first place

And I'll bring the beer for that race day!
I = (M R²)/2
How does that translate to 4x the energy? It's a exponential (aka non-linear) increase.
You don't remember anything from high-school physics do you?
So if you want to swing your internet ***** around go ahead. I'll just laugh with you. If you feel the stock parts are good because you wear out brakes...I can't help you.
I'll explain pads to you. Race pads are meant to work at higher temps and constant use. Street brakes work better at lower temps and will stop better because they are made to "panic" stop shorter (and for those cool online stats you like to think I'm looking up). So unless you are really heating up your brakes on the street, race pads aren't ideal..but I guess maybe you live your life 1 street light at at time?
I'll explain pads to you. Race pads are meant to work at higher temps and constant use. Street brakes work better at lower temps and will stop better because they are made to "panic" stop shorter (and for those cool online stats you like to think I'm looking up). So unless you are really heating up your brakes on the street, race pads aren't ideal..but I guess maybe you live your life 1 street light at at time?
Aftermarket calipers will wear out pads just as quickly as stock ones. Unless you mess with brake bias.
garbage in garbage out. You make a stupid argument, and you'll get one back. Tortional rigidity is your friend.
Last edited by G37Sam; Feb 14, 2012 at 01:30 PM. Reason: Calm down
[quote=kingdavid;3361864]
After explaining this definately go with a G37S. It will suit you just fine, much better than a base.
After explaining this definately go with a G37S. It will suit you just fine, much better than a base.
wow i dont check this for 6 hours and a bomb went off about brakes. i know that the magazines have the same complaints
1. engine oil temp sends it to limp mode
2. brake fade on their track
i have the sport brakes and this is how i upgraded, best bang for my buck i think
1. stainless steel brake lines
2. higher brake fluid temp 500 plus i think or 5DOT idk
3. STILLEN Jhook rotors, i will try to do hawk pads when i replace
1. engine oil temp sends it to limp mode
2. brake fade on their track
i have the sport brakes and this is how i upgraded, best bang for my buck i think
1. stainless steel brake lines
2. higher brake fluid temp 500 plus i think or 5DOT idk
3. STILLEN Jhook rotors, i will try to do hawk pads when i replace


