Wondering if a 19x9 +25 squares set up will work on a Sedan. Don’t want any excessive poke, and may possibly lower the car about 1.25 inches in the future.

 

My 19 x9.5 +38 is about as flush as I'd recommend, so in a 9" width that would translate into a 9 +32 offset, that +25 would poke 7mm out from mine
Here's a post of my setup for reference.
https://www.myg37.com/forums/18/2765...ml#post4044919

You can run 255/40s for a nice fit on those 9" widths.