I need 2 tires to pass inspection. I would like to get something besides the over priced OEM Dunlops.

Can I have two diff pairs?

Also, what should I get for an all season (yes I must drive in snow in the winter)

 

Having two different pairs doesn't matter, some people just think it looks weird (me). If you're looking for a performance oriented all-season I would look at Toyo Proxes-4s. I had them when I was living in Cincinnati and had an overall positive experience with them.

 

I went with the yoko avid envigors, that's what I have in the rears, stock bridgestones in front.

Decent tire for the money and awesome treadwear rating.