EcuTek and Knock Detection: Is your engine knocking?
#31
Super Moderator
iTrader: (7)
I worked at a small research plant for 27 years that did research on refinery processes. My father (BS Chemistry) was one of the founders. That's why I have a copy of the API Project 45 report. Had to learn to decipher MSDS sheets. Took a few semesters of college-level organic chemistry, too. Worked with Ph.D Chemical Engineers who were happy to answer my silly gasoline questions once I got into the Internet car thing.
#35
I am gonna run with this for a while, in the next little while I'm throwing on resonated test pipes and see if more exhaust scavenging will make for cooler engine temps and less knock.
Gonna be an interesting experiment.
#36
MORE DATA! MORE CAUSES OF KNOCK
So I installed a grounding kit (Big 3, etc.) and it caused some issues.
I went from a next to no knock to TONS of knock all over the rev range.
Temperature ranged from 70F-85F, high and low humidity, different gas stations, fresh oil, it didn't matter. I was getting knock events greater than 3* at different loads and RPM points.
All of that being said, I found this post by scarguy055
After discovering this, I removed ONLY the ground from negative battery terminal to chassis. VIOLA! All of that weird knock was gone, 100% back to the normal behavior of my tune.
I think the tolerances of my tune, plus the now inaccurate voltages, caused it to deviate enough to cause issues.
My conclusion is: if you are doing a grounding kit DO NOT ground from battery to chassis, bypassing the current sensor. Especially after a tune.
So I installed a grounding kit (Big 3, etc.) and it caused some issues.
I went from a next to no knock to TONS of knock all over the rev range.
Temperature ranged from 70F-85F, high and low humidity, different gas stations, fresh oil, it didn't matter. I was getting knock events greater than 3* at different loads and RPM points.
All of that being said, I found this post by scarguy055
This is a copy of something I posted on the DIY sticky for the grounding cables. Putting it here because this thread is more recent.
Connecting an additional cable from the battery negative terminal directly to the chassis bypasses the battery current sensor, which can impact the power generation voltage variable control system, possibly leading to improper battery charging.
If this causes the alternator to charge too often, it can cause battery over-charging, premature alternator failure and decreased fuel efficiency.
It seems to me like the additional ground to the negative terminal would cause the battery current sensor to see less of the current, making it think there was less battery use, causing it to under-charge. Not only is a weak charged battery an issue for multiple reasons, but on my 'vert could impact the top operation which is very sensitive to battery voltage.
Like many current sensors, the battery current sensor appears to be a "ring" that just sits around the factory ground cable. The factory ground cable seems very thin and the battery current sensor appears to have plenty of room to accept a much thicker cable.
Has anyone tried to replace the factory ground cable from the negative battery terminal to the chassis by running a thicker gauge ground cable through the battery current sensor?
I wonder if the decreased space between the sensor and a thicker cable would cause the sensor to incorrectly sense what it thought was a higher current, causing the alternator to run too much?
Connecting an additional cable from the battery negative terminal directly to the chassis bypasses the battery current sensor, which can impact the power generation voltage variable control system, possibly leading to improper battery charging.
If this causes the alternator to charge too often, it can cause battery over-charging, premature alternator failure and decreased fuel efficiency.
It seems to me like the additional ground to the negative terminal would cause the battery current sensor to see less of the current, making it think there was less battery use, causing it to under-charge. Not only is a weak charged battery an issue for multiple reasons, but on my 'vert could impact the top operation which is very sensitive to battery voltage.
Like many current sensors, the battery current sensor appears to be a "ring" that just sits around the factory ground cable. The factory ground cable seems very thin and the battery current sensor appears to have plenty of room to accept a much thicker cable.
Has anyone tried to replace the factory ground cable from the negative battery terminal to the chassis by running a thicker gauge ground cable through the battery current sensor?
I wonder if the decreased space between the sensor and a thicker cable would cause the sensor to incorrectly sense what it thought was a higher current, causing the alternator to run too much?
I think the tolerances of my tune, plus the now inaccurate voltages, caused it to deviate enough to cause issues.
My conclusion is: if you are doing a grounding kit DO NOT ground from battery to chassis, bypassing the current sensor. Especially after a tune.
Last edited by Slatey; 09-03-2017 at 06:41 AM.
The following users liked this post:
blnewt (09-02-2017)
#39
Registered Member
#41
Registered Member
I am looking at your posted data log and something seems odd. Compared the data logs for my ecutek tune you are running richer with less engine load and less timing but still getting ignition correction due to knock. Are you running 93 octane?
#42
Post what your logs look like if possible
#43
Registered Member
Here is a data log from a month ago covering the same rpm range as your posted log. The cam timing data is not in this log, but afr, load, ignition timing, temperatures and rpm are. The knock you are experiencing may be caused by combustion chamber deposits in your 100k mile engine. Maybe some fuel additives to clean the combustion chambers and the backs of the intake valves will help.
The following users liked this post:
Slatey (09-21-2017)
#44
Here is a data log from a month ago covering the same rpm range as your posted log. The cam timing data is not in this log, but afr, load, ignition timing, temperatures and rpm are. The knock you are experiencing may be caused by combustion chamber deposits in your 100k mile engine. Maybe some fuel additives to clean the combustion chambers and the backs of the intake valves will help.
I figured it could be carbon because it was definitely highway miles based on the amount of rock chips on my front bumper. I did a full seafoam treatment, one spray bottle for each throttle body (not simultaneously), and a canister in the fuel tank.
This seems to have definitely helped. I'm getting way less knock throughout the rev range on hot days. I say hot days because it was 92F yesterday and this has been the hottest day since I treated it and saw improvements since my last file update compared to prior hot days. Cool days dont produce much, if any knock, obviously.
My next plan of attack is figure out why I'm running lean compared to my target AFR. Your car is essentially right on your target AFR vs. Actual AFR for bank 1 and 2. My theory is maybe a vacuum leak somewhere. Unless my intake is bringing in that much air and dropping target AFR is the only way to compensate.
#45
Registered Member
Since the purpose of the grounding kit is to reduce resistance in the ground circuit, you can simply attache to the same grounding point as the battery cable instead of directly to the battery terminal. This will direct all current through the sensor. The negative battery cable is sized for the starter current load, so the running current should be no issue.