Another vote for DWS 06's here. My third set of Extreme Contacts, and I'll be hard pressed to move to another tire if they ever discontinue them. Really great all season tire, excellent in the wet and snow, dry performance is good enough for sane street driving. If you want something to autocross or track, I'd look elsewhere, but they're hard to beat.

 

Looks like my work siuation is changing and I'll be putting on a lot less miles. As such, I'm leaning towards the BFG's. Got a quote from costco and, all said and done, 4 tires mounted, balanced and nitrogen filled w/ road hazard warranty and lifetime balance/rotation/nitrogen is about $525. That's really hard to beat for new UHP rubber on a sport sedan. The continentals are looking like they'll be about $650 if i take the 45min drive down to the tirerack distribution center and get them installed nearby or $700 to have them shipped to and installed by a local shop